Top 8 Best Insoles for Shoes that are too Big – Reviews & Buying Guide

Choosing the right size of shoes is very important in order to keep your feet comfortable while wearing it and for preventing injuries. But there are cases when you simply cannot find the perfect fit for the shoes you want. Sizing up is often the best option when you are not sure about the fit of your shoes. But when they are too big, they can wreck your feet, too – whether you are walking, running, or even standing. Thankfully, there is a solution for that – insoles. 

Shoe insoles are designed as fillers that will make up for the extra shoe space.  It is a quick and easy fix so you can avoid injuries and keep your feet comfortable, too. But your ability to enjoy this benefit is only as good as the quality of the insoles you get. This guide will take you through the steps you need to find the perfect insoles for shoes that are too big, as well as a few recommendations from the ones out there in the market. 

Top 8 Best Insoles For Shoes That Are Too Big

This is a list of the best insoles for shoes that are too big. Check out the features, along with the pro’s and con’s, so you can make the best choice.

1. Superfeet Everyday Pain Relief Insoles

The Superfeet Everyday Pain Relief Insoles is one of the best yet most affordable insoles in the market, especially for those with flat feet or injured feet. Wearing shoes that are too big can further aggravate your foot condition. Hence, you need to consider this insole for relief from pain due to its shock-absorbent quality.

The Superfeet Insoles are made with cell foam that provides additional cushioning and support to your feet. This choice of material ensures lasting comfort on your feet when they would otherwise be in pain due to the ill-fitting shoes you are wearing. It provides maximum support due to the deep heel cup and the shock absorption properties of the insoles. As a result, you can get more stability with every step. 

The insoles are made with a natural coating so you can guarantee it is safe and organic. At the same time, it helps to eliminate bacteria that causes the bad odor to your feet. The Superfeet insole is also integrated with a biomechanical shape that reduces stress on your feet and ankles.

2. Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles for Men Shoe Inserts

If you have shoes that are too big, Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel is the ideal option to provide relief from pain. It is also designed for those who work on hard surfaces that can cause extreme discomfort on your heels, feet, and legs. This insole offers all-day shock absorption and cushioning so you won’t feel any pain at all.

Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles features extra forefoot cushioning so the ball of your foot is well protected. It is also equipped with cooling vents so that you can keep your feet dry and comfortable at all times. The reinforced arch support ensures proper foot alignment with every stride. Finally, the responsive wave cushioning (advanced multi-layer waves) located at the heel and arch of your foot absorbs the impact where you need it most.

With Dr. Scholl’s Work Massaging Gel Advanced Insoles, muscle and foot fatigue is a thing of the past. You can get relief from your tired and achy feet due to ill-fitting shoes or standing on hard surfaces all day. 

3. Timberland PRO Men’s Anti-Fatigue Technology Replacement Insole

The Timberland PRO Men’s Anti-Fatigue Technology Replacement Insole is another one of the best insoles for shoes that are too big. It is reasonably priced and is perfect for those who are constantly dealing with tired feet. This insole is equipped with anti-fatigue technology along with its use of open cell foam to make it breathable.

The anatomical footbed that is integrated into the design of the Timberland PRO Men’s Anti-Fatigue Technology Replacement Insole means that it can provide extensive arch support, no matter what your arch type may be. In addition to a breathable cell foam material, the insole has moisture-wicking properties that keeps your feet dry and prevents unwanted odor.

The anti-fatigue technology is without a doubt the most important feature in the Timberland PRO Men’s Anti-Fatigue Technology Replacement Insole. It is a geometrical technology that provides support and comfort all day while also absorbing shock. This makes the insole from Timberland the ideal solution for those who are working in a tedious environment. You can also expect unmatched durability given the reputation of the brand.

4. Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx

Another one on the list of the best insoles for shoes that are too big is the Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx. This is a unisex insole that is best recommended for those with constant foot aches. This one is made with a synthetic material with a rear sink cup. It promises to offer firm arch support and improved stability to your stride.

The controlled soft cushioning in the Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx provides comfort like no other. This goes well with the super footrest support so that the impact of every step is evenly distributed, even when the product is thin layered. There is also a semi-rigid texture to this insole so that there is no internal sliding and it can keep your arch where it should be. 

For those who sweat often, you need not worry because the Powerstep Pinnacle Maxx insole comes with an absorbent top layer (made of fabric). This anti-microbial fabric reduces heat that is generated on your feet to keep it from sweating and to fight off bacteria that comes from sweat. This process not only keeps your feet blister-free, but odor-free as well. 

The use of EVA foam ensures that you can get quality, comfort, durability, and extra cushioning with every step.

5. Envelop Gel Insoles – Shoe Inserts for Walking, Running, Hiking

 

If you are in need of an all-around insole for shoes that are too big, the Envelop Gel Insoles is for you. It is also one of the most affordable shoe insoles you will find in the market today. It is ideal for casual or business use, as well as for active pursuits such as hiking, walking, or running. Whether you are tackling light or heavy duties, this insole can get the job done. 

The Envelop Gel Insoles are designed to fit well in shoes that are too big for your feet. It offers the ideal stylistic impression so that you can get the support you need no matter what your shoe size. Expect all-day comfort when you put this into your shoe, even the ill-fitting ones because it comes with a cushioned lining to soften every impact of your step. It provides support from the ball of your foot to the heels.

The ergonomic design of the Envelop Gel Insoles feature honeycomb inserts that absorb shock and provide adequate stability to your feet. Thus, it won’t slip or slide when you are standing or moving. The textured base of the insole ensures that it is gripped firmly onto the base of your shoe. And yet, it is flexible enough to go with the natural movement of your feet. And since it is lightweight and flexible, it is easy to put on or off your shoes.

6. Sof Sole Insoles Men’s ATHLETE Performance Full-Length Gel Shoe Insert

Choosing the right shoe size is very important for athletic footwear. Thus, the Sof Sole Insoles were developed specifically to address the concern of ill-fitting athletic shoes so you can boost your performance. It not only improves the fit of athletic footwear but also takes the comfort level up a notch.

The neutral arch design of Sof Sole Insoles makes it an ideal solution for most foot types and arches. The insole is also designed to be lightweight so you can get added cushioning without the extra weight. The jelly pad layer on this insole reduces the impact of every motion and absorbs shock. The cushion is not just any other ones you find in other insoles; it is a hydrologic cushion that minimizes abrasion on your feet. Furthermore, you won’t have to worry about the insole slipping or sliding internally.

Another unique feature of the Sof Sole Insoles is the breathability of the material. The hydrologic cushion helps to wick away any excess moisture from your sweat. If there is any, it dissipates quickly to keep your feet dry and to fight any unwanted odor. This is, therefore, the best product to address any type of insole issues, especially if your shoes are too big.

7. VoMii PU Memory Foam Insoles Plantar Fasciitis Arch Support Insoles

 

The VoMii PU Memory Foam Insoles is another budget-friendly option for anyone looking for the best insoles for shoes that are too big. This is a versatile shoe insert because it is recommended for casual use, as well as for athletic performance. It is also designed to address issues such as foot pain, shock absorption, and relief for plantar fasciitis. 

Available at less than $10 in some online retailers, the VoMii PU Memory Foam is a good investment for your foot health. It offers an ergonomic design and high arch support. It starts with the use of highly elastic memory foam that delivers superior performance. It also boasts of a U shape heel cup structure and neutral arch support. This gives the insoles maximum stability and reduces the impact on those with flat feet. 

This memory foam insole also works best in reducing foot pressure with its shock-absorbing properties. It is ideal for chronic sufferers of muscle fatigue and helps prevent foot problems like plantar fasciitis and heel spurs. Whether you are walking or jogging, this feels like clouds on your feet. The combination of velvet and PU material is medically graded to remove sweat and other types of moisture. 

8. Leather Heel Grips Liner,Non Slip Inserts for Men Women Shoes Too Big

The leather heel grips liner from Makryn is a non-slip insert that is ideal for both men and women. It is designed as shoe fillers when you are wearing a size that is too big for your feet so you can get a better fit and to prevent injuries. The insole is available in two thickness levels so you can adjust according to how much extra shoe space you need to fill. It is also available in three color options: khaki, beige, and black.

When you purchase this insole, you will get one pair – one for each foot. It is the best option for filling in the gaps when you are wearing larger shoes. It is made with high quality leather so it is long-lasting with proper care. At the same time, it is made with soft leather materials so it won’t cause any blisters or abrasions when worn. It comes with a soft padding for additional cushioning and comfort. 

The leather heel grips liner from Makryn also comes with a strong self-adhesive. Hence, you won’t have to worry about it being forced out of position. Not only does it prevent abrasion but it gives your shoes a better fit.

How to Buy a Pair of Best Shoe Insole?

Why is it important to buy insoles if your shoes are too big? It’s clear that there are detrimental effects to your foot health when you wear shoes that are too small. However, there are also risks involved if you wear shoe sizes that are too big. First off, you could suffer from blisters and chafing – these can cause you tremendous pain and discomfort when walking or even standing! It can also be a tripping hazard or put on too much stress on certain areas of your feet, resulting in foot fatigue. 

Keeping a snug fit on your shoes is crucial here; which is why you need to invest in the best shoe insoles to compensate for the extra space. Take note of the features that you need to look for when you are buying insoles for shoes that are too big:

1. Size of the insole

Getting the right size of insole is crucial in order to achieve the right fit. To choose the right size, you have to know the shoe size and the actual size of your feet. You must determine the difference in order to choose the right filler so you can keep your feet comfortable while wearing them. 

2. Foot type

Every individual’s foot is different. Therefore, it pays to know the unique characteristics of your feet in order to choose the right insoles. In particular, consider the arch type of your feet and make sure that the insoles you choose correspond to that. The arch is a very important feature if you want to get adequate support with your insoles. 

3. Insole material

It goes without saying that you should always look into the type of material used when buying insoles for shoes that are too big. The most common materials used for shoe insoles are gel, leather, and cork. Every type of material is unique so it is important to understand these differences so you can choose accordingly. 

Gel insoles are extremely soft so they give optimum comfort to your feet while absorbing shock. Cork insoles are great if you want a naturally breathable material with good cushioning. Finally, the leather insoles are long lasting and effective at absorbing moisture. 

EVA insoles are also some of the best in the market. 

4. Footbed type

For the best results with your use of insoles, make sure you choose the right type of footbed. Depending on the type of footbed you choose, it can offer full, rigid, semi-rigid, or flat cushion arch support. This is why it is important to know your arch type and the level of support you need. 

FAQs

Do you need to break in insoles?

It depends on the type of insole you choose. However, insoles should not make your feet uncomfortable because they are designed primarily to provide additional support and comfort for ill-fitting shoes. If it cannot provide that, then you should avoid wearing them altogether.

What are the different types of insoles?

There are many to choose from in the market such as heel support insoles. This type of insole covers the partial heel cup along with your entire sole. They are ideal for shoes that are too big since they provide additional heel support.

Gel insoles are another type of insoles for shoes that are too big. This type of material is popular because it is extremely soft with adequate cushioning and lots of comfort. It is recommended if you have existing feet or joint pain.

The orthotic insoles provide heel, arch, and metatarsal support. This is the best option for those looking to optimize their foot alignment. 

Finally, there are arch support insoles. This is recommended for those with high or low arch (flat feet) that experience tremendous amounts of pressure on their feet when they walk or run. 

How long do they last?

Even the best quality insoles do not last forever. When used regularly, most would last between six months to a year. Once it is past that stage, it is best to replace them; otherwise, they won’t be as effective in providing additional support for your feet. 

Use the information above to help you find the best insoles for shoes that are too big. Otherwise, you could compromise your foot health or risk developing injuries and discomfort. With the right insole, you can save yourself the trouble and you can still put your oversized shoes to good use.